Collection: Single Cookies

Filter:

Availability
0 selected Reset
Price
The highest price is $5.25 Reset
$
$

31 products

Filter and sort

Filter and sort

31 of 31 products

Availability
Price

The highest price is $5.25

$
$

31 products

  • Maple Pecan
    Maple Pecan
    Flavor Details
    Regular price
    $5.25 USD
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $5.25 USD
    Title

    A thick, soft maple syrup-sweetened cookie with a tender crumb. Pecans blended throughout the dough add a satisfying crunch. Our brand new maple glaze drips down the sides, lending the perfect touch of sweetness!

  • Lava Cake
    Lava Cake
    Flavor Details
    Regular price
    $5.25 USD
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $5.25 USD
    Title

    Just like your favorite dessert, but in cookie form! A more cake-like double chocolate brownie cookie filled with a homemade hot fudge filling, and topped with powdered sugar. Our most chocolatey cookie yet! Serve at room temp for a delicious fudge filling or warmed up for a flow of hot chocolate lava! 


    The Lava Cake cookie is all cake and all cookies with a homemade fudge filling and topped with powdered sugar. Warm it up for a hot fudge lava expansion or eat at room temperature for a thicker fudge-like experience.

  • Cinnamon Bun
    Cinnamon Bun
    Flavor Details
    Regular price
    $5.25 USD
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $5.25 USD
    Title

    Ever wondered what would happen if we slapped a cinnamon bun into a Taylor Chip cookie? We took everything you know and love about the traditional moist, sweet, sticky pastry and elevated it with our signature bourbon vanilla glaze!

  • PB Explosion
    PB Explosion
    Flavor Details
    Regular price
    $5.25 USD
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $5.25 USD
    Title

    This Hershey exclusive is an explosion of all the best peanut butter candies with every bite! If the sweet filling of a peanut butter cup is your fav, that’s exactly what this cookie tastes like so it’s bound to be your fav too😋

  • Brookie
    Brookie
    Flavor Details
    Regular price
    $5.25 USD
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $5.25 USD
    Title

    The perfect combination of the Double Chocolate Brownie and our Classic Chocolate Chip cookies. We combined two of our fan favorites into one gooey cookie goodness you are sure to love.

  • Chocolate Chip
    Chocolate Chip
    Flavor Details
    Regular price
    $5.25 USD
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $5.25 USD
    Title

    The cookie that started it all! Inspired by a cookie that was made with vegetable shortening, the goal was to create a cookie that had that same density and thickness but with simple, natural, ingredients. It took us over a year, but we made it even better. Most would say, it’s the best cookie they ever had.

  • Chocolate Chip Biscuit
    Chocolate Chip Biscuit
    Flavor Details
    Regular price
    $5.25 USD
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $5.25 USD
    Title

    50% less sugar than our normal cookies and a great option for breakfast! Our biscuit is the perfect blend of cookie biscuit and scone. This is a completely new experience.

  • Double Chocolate Brownie
    Double Chocolate Brownie
    Flavor Details
    Regular price
    $5.25 USD
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $5.25 USD
    Title

    The perfect blend of cookie and brownie. We put in a double portion of rich, intense dutch processed cocoa and combine that with a copious amount of local chocolate from Lititz, Pennsylvania.

  • Gluten Free Loaded Peanut Butter
    Gluten Free Loaded Peanut Butter
    Flavor Details
    Regular price
    $5.25 USD
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $5.25 USD
    Title

    Our Free From Gluten Loaded Peanut Butter cookie is made with our own blend of minimally processed flour substitutes. This all-natural, locally made, peanut butter cookie has 100% American peanut butter heavily mixed into the dough. Loaded with a glob of peanut butter in the middle, this cookie is a peanut butter lover’s dream.

    Disclaimer: These amazing cookies are made with natural Peanut Butter, oils may separate in transit.

  • Gluten-free Brookie
    Gluten-free Brookie
    Flavor Details
    Regular price
    $5.25 USD
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $5.25 USD
    Title

    Our Free From Gluten Brookie cookie is made with our own blend of minimally processed flour substitutes.The perfect combination of the Double Chocolate Brownie and our Classic Chocolate Chip cookies. We combined two of our fan favorites into one gooey cookie goodness you are sure to love.

  • Gluten-Free Chocolate Chip
    Gluten-Free Chocolate Chip
    Flavor Details
    Regular price
    $5.25 USD
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $5.25 USD
    Title

    Our Free From Gluten Chocolate Chip cookie is made with our own blend of minimally processed flour substitutes. Based on the cookie that started it all, it took the perfect combination of specialty flours and the right taste before we felt good about adding this gluten free cookie to the line up and are proud to say we couldn’t be happier with it.

  • Gluten-free Double Chocolate Brownie
    Gluten-free Double Chocolate Brownie
    Flavor Details
    Regular price
    $5.25 USD
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $5.25 USD
    Title

    Our Free From Gluten Chocolate Chip cookie is made with our own blend of minimally processed flour substitutes. The perfect blend of cookie and brownie. We put in a double portion of rich, intense dutch processed cocoa and combine that with a copious amount of local chocolate from Lititz, Pennsylvania.

  • Loaded Peanut Butter
    Loaded Peanut Butter
    Flavor Details
    Regular price
    $5.25 USD
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $5.25 USD
    Title

    An all-natural, locally made, peanut butter cookie with 100% American peanut butter heavily mixed into the dough. Loaded with a glob of peanut butter in the middle, this cookie is a peanut butter lover’s dream.

    Disclaimer: These amazing cookies are made with natural Peanut Butter, oils may separate in transit.

  • M&M
    M&M
    Flavor Details
    Regular price
    $5.25 USD
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $5.25 USD
    Title

    This M&M candy cookie is a favorite for kids and adults alike. A dark brown sugary base with a lot of M&Ms scattered throughout the dough and then carefully place on top for that extra color and candy crunch.

  • Oatmeal Raisin
    Oatmeal Raisin
    Flavor Details
    Regular price
    $5.25 USD
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $5.25 USD
    Title

    A huge, soft, gooey version of the oatmeal raisin everyone loves. This cookie is wonderfully decadent with just the right number of raisins. Finished with a light cinnamon flavor and always gooey in the middle.

  • Oreos & Cream
    Oreos & Cream
    Flavor Details
    Regular price
    $5.25 USD
    Regular price
    Sale price
    $5.25 USD
    Title

    We put in about 4 to 5 Oreos per cookie by blending the Oreos super fine and then dumping a ton in each batch of our Oreos & Cream cookies. Finished off with an Oreo on top and then baked in the oven to perfection.